My child is a fucking brat. No two ways about it. What I can do about it is a puzzle to me. Should I remove my own feelings and just try to deal with her, like maybe the way some sort of emotionally removed therapist might? Do I have a duty to tell her of my feelings, demonstrating them by my tone of voice? It's such a frustrating situation that I find myself emotionally disconnecting from her.
I've been thinking about the whole Non-Violent Communication and why it doesn't work for us, beyond the fact that I don't use it, that is. The NVC books actually deal somewhat of criticism that people will feel psychoanalyzed. The response is to go even more simpler, in ways that aren't as comfortable or normal to us as people as this faux analysis is. To actually reflect the feelings on a very basic level. And if you are wrong, the person will correct you. It seems from the time she was old enough to understand what I was doing with trying to reflect her feelings, she fought against it.
When she was 4:
Me: "You're sad because you can't have the toy you want."
Bug, screaming in rage: "I'm not sad! I'm not sad! I'm not sad! I'm HAPPY!"
When she was 5:
Me: "You're sad because you really want the toy, but we can't buy it."
Bug, screaming: "I'm not sad, I'm MAD. NOW BUY ME THE TOY!"
Now that she's 6:
Me: "I understand you are really sad and angry about this, but we can't buy that toy right now."
Bug, nastily: "I am angry and it's your fault! If you weren't so stupid and only cared about yourself, you would get it for me."
These are just my memories, and I don't know that they are completely accurate, except for her screaming through her tears that she was happy and I couldn't tell her she wasn't because I don't know her brain. I have tried to reflect her feelings from an early age, even before she had a voice to do so. She didn't talk until late, and she's always had some of the emotional intensity found in the "spirited children." Bean seems to me a very typical two year old, doing two year old things, having huge screaming hitting tantrums at times, but they seem more easy to deal with, more like a normal toddler meltdown. Maybe I'm just better at reading her.
With Bug, most of the time I just tried to soothe her through the tantrum, and if it didn't work or I found myself getting too angry, I left her alone (on the floor while I sat in a chair or stood nearby). Sometimes I'd try giving her words for her emotions. But as she has told me, I don't know her brain, I don't know how things are in "Bugland" and apparently there are completely different laws in her own world.
So the reason NVC doesn't work to me when I try it in earnestness is manifold, from all of us being unused to this type of communication, DH not finding any value in it, me trying to overanalyze instead of just objectively reflect. And maybe even sometimes it is working, but I expect it to be easier. However, I am reluctant to even try and use NVC because I don't believe it will work. I am afraid that my child will prove to be beyond the capacity for empathy. For so long she has been incapable of empathy, and I always felt like that was my fault, that her own emotional needs were not being met because of my own tendency to get angry and close down when the going got difficult, which is how I've responded to things for most of my life. So I've kept trying, alternately trying to model an empathic caring response (even if it wasn't what I felt) and then flying off the handle and snapping at her. This has created the worst of both worlds (permissiveness vs. authoritarian). I rarely strike the balance of assertive parenting, the kind that has useful limits that can be accepted, maybe not easily, but eventually.
Recently I've begun to realize that Bug just doesn't know or understand that some things are hurtful. She truly doesn't know. I've gotten much more likely to punish her by sending her to her room once I feel that trying to be playful, reflect and empathize is going down like a plane on fire. She doesn't get that telling someone in a sarcastic tone, "and just where did I say turkey in that sentence" or saying "I've never felt sorry for you or cared about your feelings" in a sincere voice can be hurtful. She thinks she is telling the truth, and I have certainly told her enough that I'm not going to punish her for her feelings, I want to know them.
But ultimately, when I move into what I see as an NVC dialogue, in the back of my mind I know I am doing it not because I really want to understand her, but just because I want to fix her. I want her to feel empathy, and I want to get my own way. I'm not truly prepared for the discourse to move in it's own direction, with maybe me having to give up some of my desires. Goodness knows I've given up enough of my desires on matters to let my child have hers. In the back of my mind, however, I feel like it is a compromise. There is an unwritten score card, and I'll be able to pull out my, "Hey, remember when you got to have this? Now it's my turn" card. And it doesn't work like that. I give up things I can and that won't hurt me too much so that down the road I can stand my ground on the one thing that really matters. And it doesn't work, because Bug doesn't really understand or even care that this is what I'm doing, and our interactions lose that honesty that they should have if we were both truly open.



Recent Comments